"Nyika hadzigone kuve nemafungiro akasiyana paMutemo we Union Legal News

Mifananidzo neMondelMedia

José Miguel Barjola.- Mutungamiriri weDare reJustice reEuropean Union, Koen Lenaerts, akasimbisa neChishanu chino, mumabiko akaitwa muMadrid, kukosha kwekudzivirira hutongi hwemutemo munyika dziri nhengo dzeMubatanidzwa uye kugarisana. chikumbiro chako nevatongi venyika imwe neimwe. Zvakazviita mutafura yakatenderedza yekodzero dzakakosha, yakarongwa neCarlos Amberes Foundation nerutsigiro rweWolters Kluwer Foundation uye Mutualidad Abogacía, izvo zvakaitika kuRoyal Academy yeMoral and Political Sciences.

Munguva yekushanya kwake kuguta guru reSpain, mumiriri wepamusoro-soro weEuropean Justice akadzivirira chinangwa chekuwana hurongwa hwekutonga hunoenderana munharaunda yenharaunda. Izvo hazvireve, akadaro, kuudza nyika maitiro adzinofanirwa kuita mutemo kana sarudzo dzekuita.

“Ibasa reCJEU here kujekesa musimboti uyu [zvakakosha zveRule of Law] asi kwete zvekusvika pakutaurira nyika kuti dzinoronga sei gutsaruzhinji, hutongi hwadzo nedzimwe nyaya dzebumbiro remitemo. kugona kwenhengo imwe neimwe yenyika", akadaro.

Chiitiko ichi chakaunza pamwe minondo mikuru yemasangano ekutonga eSpain. Francisco Marín Castán, purezidhendi weBato Rokutanga (weZvinhu Zvevanhu), akatsanangura pamberi peLenaerts kuti Dare Repamusorosoro rakafunga “zvakakwana” kuti kwaiva neboka guru rinotsanangura mutemo maererano nenheyo dzenzanga. "Zvakakosha kuti tizive uye tifunge kuti kune vatongi vekutanga kana vatongi vematunhu vanogona kukurukura nezvehutongi hweDare Repamusorosoro pamberi peCJEU," akatsanangura. Semunhu anopikisa, akanyunyuta kuti kubvunzurudzwa nguva dzose kwekutonga kweDare Repamusorosoro pamberi peCJEU kunogona kutungamirira ku "kuunganidza nyaya dzisina kugadziriswa", chinhu chinowanzoitika mu "nyaya dzekuchengetedzwa kwevatengi".

Nezve dambudziko re IRPH, Marín akatsanangura se "zvinoshamisa" uye nyaya "kuganhurana pane zvisinganzwisisiki" kunyunyuta kwe "kambani yezvemitemo inozivikanwa inoita zvakawanda zvekushambadza" kune magistrates anoverengeka eDare Repamusorosoro nekuda kwekutanga uye kumanikidza. . Masvondo mashoma apfuura, hofisi yeArriaga Asociados yakazivisa kukwidzwa kwemhosva kune mamejasitiriti mana eChamber, anotungamirwa naMarin Castán. Muchinyorwa, akapomera magistrates nezve prevarication uye mhosva yekumanikidza.

Nokuda kwake, María Teresa Fernández de la Vega, purezidhendi weDare reHurumende, akasimbisa basa reboka rinopa mazano rokugadzirira magwaro epamutemo. Saizvozvo, akadzivirira pfungwa yekuti Rule yeMutemo haigone kutora modhi yakanga isiri "yemagariro, ecological uye egalitarian".

"Muchikamu cheEuropean Union kune Nyika dzinomiririra dambudziko rekudzivirira hunhu hunosanganisira Kodzero Dzakakosha. Uye imwe yeaya akakosha misimboti kuenzana, "akadaro jurist uye aimbova mutevedzeri wemutungamiri wehurumende, akataura pachena Poland neHungary. Muchikumbiro chekuvaka "State of Social Law", De la Vega akasimbisa kuti "democracy haina kukwana kana kusimbisa kuri parusununguko chete, kukanganwa kuenzana". “Kuenzana kunoda hutongi hwejekerere, kwete chitunha,” vakapedzisa.

Koen Lenaerts, Mutungamiri weCJEU:

Kubva kuruboshwe kuenda kurudyi: Pedro González-Trevijano (purezidhendi weTC), Koen Lenaerts (purezidhendi weCJEU), Cristina Sancho (purezidhendi weWolters Kluwer Foundation) naMiguel Ángel Aguilar (purezidhendi weCarlos de Amberes Foundation). Kunobva: Mondelo Media.

Pedro González-Trevijano, purezidhendi weDare reConstitutional Court, akakurudzira nechido “kukurukurirana pakati penzvimbo” kuti pave nekududzirwa kunopindirana kwemitemo yenyika nenharaunda. Nzira iyo yakakosha "kudzivisa sarudzo dzinopesana," akadaro. Sezvaakatsanangura, matare ebumbiro reEuropean "ari kuzvibatanidza kuti ave nani nemibvunzo yekutanga", sezvo 18 muzana yemitongo yedare rebumbiro reSpain ine "mareferensi akachena kudare reLuxembourg neStrasbourg", uye nhamba "inokwira 68% mumunda wekuchengetedza zviwanikwa", iyo inoratidza nzira yakanaka yemasangano eSpanish mukuenderana kwavo nehunhu hweMubatanidzwa. "Zvinogona kutaurwa kuti Spanish TC iri kutora maitiro ayo kuEuropeanist paramita."