Dare reJustice reEuropean Union (CJEU) rakaziva, nekutonga, ruzivo rwebasa revashandi vehutano kunze kwenyika nechinangwa chevakuru. Dare reEuropean Court rakafunga nyaya inokuvadza yakasimudzwa neConstitious-Administrative Chamber yeTSJCyL muValladolid izvo zvichagoneka kuziva vanachiremba uye vanamukoti vakashanda muNhengo dzeNyika nguva yebasa rebasa nekuda kwezvinangwa kwete chete. zvevakuru asiwo zvebasa rekutonga.
Sarudzo yeCJEU inopindura kumubvunzo unokuvadza wakamutswa neChamber uye inoratidza kuti ruzivo rwehunyanzvi rwakawanikwa nemunhu akavharirwa muchipatara cheSanta María de Lisboa harufanirwe kuverengerwa mukucherechedzwa kwete chete kwemakore matatu emakore ekukwegura. asiwo pazvinoreva basa rehunyanzvi muAutonomous Health Service.
Kufamba kwevanhu vakasununguka
Pamusoro pemirau, Dare rakavakirwa pakufamba kwakasununguka kwevanhu vane chinangwa chekufambisa vagari vemuEurope uye kushandiswa kwerudzi rwakadai rwebasa rehunyanzvi munharaunda yeMubatanidzwa uye rinopokana nenzira dzinogona kuisa zvizvarwa izvi munzvimbo isina kunaka. mamiriro ezvinhu kana vachida kuita basa rehupfumi mune imwe Nhengo yeNyika.
Zvikurukuru uye nezvevashandi, Dare rinorangarira mutemo waro maererano nemitemo yenyika inorambidza kana kurambidza mushandi kubva munyika yake kuti ashandise kodzero yake yekufamba akasununguka inoumba zvirambidzo parusununguko rwakadaro. Uye izvi zvinogona kuitika kana zvisingatarisi nguva dzese dzebasa rekuita kusvika pamwero wekuti zvinogona kuita kuti kufamba kwakasununguka kwevashandi kuve kushoma.
Dare reJustice rakaona kuti rusarura rwakarambidzwa runogona kuve rwakananga kana kuti rusina kunanga. Pamusoro pezvo, inobvuma kuti panogona kuve nezvirambidzo kana vakatevera chinangwa chezvido zvakajairika, zvakakwana kuvimbisa kuzadzikiswa kwechinangwa chataurwa uye zvisingapfuuri zvinodikanwa kuti zvizadzike.
Nekudaro, vachishandisa iyi proportionality bvunzo kune chaiyo nyaya, CJEU inopedzisira yaona kuti, kunyangwe kana zviremera zveSpain zvichitsvaga zviri pamutemo kuvimbisa zvinhu uye kurongeka kwebasa rehutano, chokwadi ndechekuti Union yakamisa hurongwa hwekucherechedzwa kwemazita. uye madiploma anobvumira kuvimbisa chinangwa chakadaro chemhando.
