Supreme anodzima hurongwa hwemari hwe "social bond" pasina kukanganisa mashandisirwo ekuderedzwa · Nhau dzeMutemo

Dare Repamusorosoro rakazivisa kuti nzira yezvemari yebhonasi yemagariro yakagadzwa neDecree-law muna 2016 inopesana nemutemo weEuropean Union wekusarura mamwe makambani ari muchikamu chemagetsi kune mamwe.

Bhonasi yemagariro ibhenefiti yemagariro anoitirwa kuchengetedza vamwe vatengi ("vatengi vari munjodzi") inosanganisira kushandisa kuderedzwa pamutengo wemagetsi anopedzwa mukugara kwavo. Sarudzo yeDare Repamusorosoro inosarudza nzira yekubhadhara mari inotarisirwa kubhadhara mutengo wekuderedzwa uku, zvikasadaro inokanganisa kuenderera kwechikumbiro chayo. Mune dzimwe nyika dzeEuropean Union, vanofanoona kuti mari iyi ichabhadharwa kubva kumari yavo yese, asi Spain yakasarudza kubva pakutanga kuita chisungo ichi kune mamwe makambani muchikamu chemagetsi.

Pane zviitiko zvakapfuura apo Dare Repamusorosoro rakaona kuti nzira yekubhadhara mari yakagadzwa nemutemo weSpain yaipesana nemutemo weEuropean Union. Iyo hurongwa hwemari yakazivisa kuti ikozvino yave kudzorwa neRoyal Decree Law 7/2016, yaDecember 23, iyo yakatemera mutengo wayo "kumakambani evabereki vemapoka emakambani anoita basa rekutengesa magetsi kana nemakambani ivo pachavo vavanoda." ita izvi kana vasiri chikamu cheboka ripi zvaro”, izvo zvaireva kugovera 94% yemutengo wekupa mari kumakambani ekushambadzira. Hurongwa hwemari uhu, sehuviri hwapfuura, hwakanzi hunopesana nemutemo weEuropean Union nemitongo yeDare Repamusorosoro ichangobva kuziviswa.

European Court

Mitongo iyi inobva pakutonga kweDare Rezvemitemo reEuropean Union, kunyanya zvakataurwa mumutongo waro wakaitwa musi wa14 Gumiguru, 2021 (Case C-683/19) umo zvichinzi zvisungo zvebasa rehurumende, zvakadai se iyo yatiri kubata nayo, inofanira kuiswa "kazhinji" pamakambani emagetsi uye kwete kune mamwe makambani chaiwo. Muchirevo chechinyorwa chino, hurongwa hwekugadzira makambani anotarisira zvisungo zvebasa revanhu haagone kusabvisa a priori a priori makambani anoshanda muchikamu chemagetsi. Naizvozvo, mutsauko upi noupi unobvira mukurapa unofanira kururamiswa nenzira yakarurama”. CJEU inowedzera kuti kana Nhengo yeNyika inosarudza kuisa chisungo chekupa mari chete mamwe makambani ari muchikamu ichi "... zviri kudare ... kutarisa kana pakanga paine musiyano pakati pemakambani anofanira kutakura huremu akati mutoro uye avo vakaregererwa nawo unoruramiswa zvine mutsindo.

Dare Repamusorosoro rinoongorora zvikonzero zvakashandiswa nemumiriri wenyika kuyedza kuita chirevo chayo pabhizinesi remakambani emagetsi, kusasanganisa makambani anoshanda muchikamu chemagetsi (jenareta, vatakuri, vanogovera) kusvika pamhedzisiro yekuti hurongwa hwakagadzirirwa mari inopesana. kune chinyorwa 3. 2 yeDirective 2009/72/EC nekuti haina chikonzero chechikonzero uye inosarura kumakambani anotora mutengo, kwaanozodzosera mari inobhadharwa mukushandiswa kweiyo yakanzurwa system.

Mutongo weDare Repamusorosoro haukanganisi kushandiswa kwekuderedzwa kwebhonasi yemagariro mukubhadharisa kwevamwe vatengi vari munjodzi, asi inozivisa nzira yakatarwa yekubhadhara mari isingashandiswe.