INkantolo Ephakeme ikuchithile ngenxa yokuntuleka kwezizathu zokungabandakanywa kokulwa nezinkunzi endaweni yokufakwa kwesicelo se-Youth Cultural Bonus.
I-Chamber isivumile isikhalazo sokuphatha esinezingxabano esifakwe yi-Fundación Toro de Lidia ngokumelene ne-Royal Decree 210/2022, yangomhla zingama-22 kuNdasa, lapho ifuna izinkambiso zokulawula zeBhonasi eshiwo ngenhla futhi ichithe inkulumo ethi "kanye nokulwa nezinkunzi" esihlokweni sayo esithi 8.2 .
I-athikili yesi-8 esigabeni sayo sesi-2 iveze ukuthi imidlalo yokulwa nezinkunzi ibonisa, ngaphezu kwezemidlalo, kanye nokutholwa kwemikhiqizo yokubhalela, izincwadi zezifundo (eziphrintiwe noma zedijithali); ikhompuyutha nemishini kagesi, isofthiwe, ihadiwe nezinto ezisetshenziswayo, izinto zobuciko, izinsimbi zomculo, imfashini kanye ne-gastronomy.
ukubonakaliswa kwamasiko
INkantolo ichaza ukuthi akukhona kuyo ukunquma ukuthi ukulwa nezinkunzi, ngokujwayelekile, kanye nemibukiso yokulwa nezinkunzi, ikakhulukazi, kuwukubonakaliswa kwamasiko, njengoba bekuyisishayamthetho esifanayo esikwenze lokho ngokuvuma, njengoba uMthetho 18 uchaza ngokucacile. /2013 yokulawula ukulwa nezinkunzi njengefa lamasiko. wengeze ngokuthi iNkantolo yoMthethosisekelo iphinde yakwenza kwacaca ukuthi uhlobo olufanayo lwesiko lokulwa nezinkunzi, okuyinto iSimemezelo SaseNdlunkulu esiphonselwe inselelo, kodwa kunalokho, ngokuphambene, sithatha ngokuthi sinalolo hlobo, ngakho-ke, kufanele sibacindezele ngokusobala.
Isiphetho siwukuthi inkantolo ukuthi akukho efayeleni noma embhalweni we-Royal Decree 210/2022 ngokwawo, njengoba kuqokonyiswe icala, azikho izizathu ezichaza ukukhishwa. "Lezo ezinikezwa yisethulo salo azibonakali zifanelekile kule njongo futhi ithi kuphela imibukiso yokulwa nezinkunzi ithuthukiswa ngezinye izisetshenziswa nokuthi Ukuphatha ngakunye kunamandla okunquma imikhakha noma imisebenzi yentshisekelo yomphakathi noma usizo oluyikhuthazayo futhi Uyakwenza,” kusho umusho, owethulwe imantshi uPablo Lucas.
Ku-Chamber, lezi zincazelo ezijwayelekile, nokho, "azanele" uma kunezinhlinzeko ezithile zomthetho ezibeka kuziphathimandla zikahulumeni isibopho sokwenza kahle endaweni ethile, njengokulwa nezinkunzi.
Ngenxa yalesi sizathu, icabange ukuthi incazelo enikezwe uMthetho 18/2013 egunyeni lezindatshana 44 no-46 zoMthethosisekelo ihlanganisa nesidingo "sokuthethelela okukodwa kwenhlangano eyanele yokuthi kungani imibukiso yokulwa nezinkunzi ishiywa ngaphandle kweBhonasi Yesiko Lentsha" .
I-Chamber ikuqinisekisile ukuthi ayikutholi lokhu kuthethelelwa kokunye okungafakwanga okufakwe ku-athikili 8.2 ye-Royal Decree 210/2022 noma, njengoba kungekho ubunikazi noma ukuxhumana phakathi kwakho okusivumela ukuthi sithole isizathu sokungafakwa esithinta thina, ngakho-ke. , ngaphandle kokungabaza ukubaluleka ngamunye anakho, kuyenzeka ukuthi ngokuphathelene nabanye akukho ukuqashelwa okungokomthetho njengalokhu okukhona maqondana nokulwa nezinkunzi ngokwesiko, umlando kanye nobukhulu bobuciko”.
Isinqumo sibhekisela eqinisweni lokuthi Ummeli Wombuso ugcizelela ukuthi i-General State Administration ithobela isibopho sayo sokugqugquzela Ukulwa Nezinkunzi, njengoba kufakazelwa imizamo efana (i) Nomklomelo Kazwelonke Wokulwa Nezinkunzi waminyaka yonke wama-€30.000; (ii) ukunikezwa kwama-€35.000 kuSisekelo esiqhubekayo sokuhlanganiswa kolwazi nemisebenzi yobuciko, yokudala nekhiqizayo ehlanganiswe Ekulweni Nezinkunzi; (iii) iphrojekthi "Yamasiko Enkunzi" yezenzo zokuhlonza, ukubhala, ukuphenya, ukubaluleka kanye nokudlulisa amagugu amasiko axhumene nokulwa nezinkunzi, avezwe kuphrojekthi ethi "Cultures of the bull in state museums" ehlanganisa imibukiso emincane emithathu. zishicilelwe futhi enye isalungiswa; (iv) umbukiso othi "Inkumbulo yokulwa nezinkunzi: izithombe zokulwa nezinkunzi ezigciniwe zombuso" zemibukiso emibili ebanjelwe (i-Salamanca ne-Seville) kanti omunye uyalungiswa e-Sanlúcar de Barrameda.
I-Chamber iphendula ngokuthi, ngisho nokuqonda ukuthi lezi zinhlelo - okuyilezo esezivele zisohlwini Lombiko Wokuhlaziywa Komthelela Olawulayo- zibhekisela esanduleleni seSimemezelo Sasebukhosini 210/2022 lapho sikhuluma ngokuzimela kanye namandla Okuphatha mayelana nokuthi yini okufanele ikhethwe futhi kanjani. ukukhuthaza isiko, ukunquma, ukwamukela ukuthi akuzona izici a posteriori, "akubonakali kithi, nokho, ukuthi bayasiza ukulungisa ukuntuleka kwezizathu zokukhishwa ngenxa yesizathu esilula sokuthi bagcina isikhathi".
Ngakolunye uhlangothi, igcizelela ukuthi "ukuvumelana kwe-Youth Cultural Bonus kunombono ojwayelekile futhi, ngaphezu kwalokho, kungase kudinge iziqu njengoba kukhuluma nesizukulwane esisha, okungukuthi, kubheka ikusasa elimelwe abantu abasha -ngokusho ngokombono woMkhandlu Wombuso cishe u-500.000 - umbono obalulekile uma kuziwa ekongiweni nasekukhuthazeni amagugu amasiko. Ngakho-ke, akukho, phakathi kwezenzo ezishiwo kanye ne-Youth Cultural Bonus -okwakusho ama-euro ayizigidi ezingu-210 esikhumbuzo sedolobha-isilinganiso esidingekayo sokuphetha ngokuthi ukulwa nezinkunzi kwanikezwa impatho elinganiselayo ngokubaluleka okuqashelwa yisishayamthetho".
