Ƙarfin Ƙarfi da Ƙarfin Ƙarfi

Daga cikin dimbin zagi da zage-zage da cin zarafi da aka yi a cikin 'yan kwanakin nan a kan kotun tsarin mulkin kasar, mafi yawan mambobinta, sun nuna ra'ayin da ke kokarin jaddada matsayin da ake dauka a matsayin ficewar majalisar, har ma da karfin ikon kotun tsarin mulki na cewa. a cikin sabon tsari, shine mafi girman ma'auni na biyayya ga ikon jama'a ga Kundin Tsarin Mulki. Wannan ra'ayin ya dogara ne akan kuskuren rubutun da majalisar ta haɗa da ikon mallakar jama'a, a matsayin ikon da ya dace, ba tare da iyakancewa ba. Kamar yadda za mu iya gani a cikin labarin 66 na Kundin Tsarin Mulki, Cortes suna wakiltar mutanen Spain, amma ba su da ikon mallaka. Suna wakiltar mutane a cikin tsarin mulkin tsarin mulkinsu na yau da kullun, amma ba su da ikon mallaka, wanda ya ci gaba da kasancewa a cikin mutanen Spain (Mataki na 1.2 AZ), daga cikin abin da ya fito, a matsayin iko, duka na Jiha. Babu wanda yake sama da ɗayan. A guda ɗaya, Kotuna ba su da wani iko da ya wuce kundin tsarin mulki, tun da rashin cin zarafin wakilai da Sanatoci, misali na 66.3 na Kundin Tsarin Mulki, ba ya nufin kariyar dokokinsu. Akasin haka yana nufin ɗaukar hanyar Yarjejeniyar Ƙasa ta Faransa ta 1792, misali, a cikin Carl Schmitt's terminology, na mulkin kama-karya na ikon da ya ƙi yarda da duk wani iyaka a cikin aiwatar da ayyukansa, kuma yana ƙoƙarin ƙaddamar da kansa akan kowane farashi. kuma a kowane farashi, kamar yadda yarjejeniyar ta ce ta hanyar abin da ake kira Kwamitin Kiwon Lafiyar Jama'a. Matsakaicin Labaran da ke da alaƙa Ee Kotun tsarin mulki ta dakatar da shirin shari'a na Sánchez Nati Villanueva Da kuri'u shida zuwa biyar, majistare na TC sun yanke shawarar gurgunta gyare-gyaren da PSOE da UP suka gabatar don yin gyara a Majalisa kuma ta hanyar ƙofar baya CGPJ da TC Bayan yakin duniya na biyu, dala Kelsenian na al'ada dala ya yi arziki, wanda kundin tsarin mulki ya kafa, yana ba da takamaiman jiki, kotu ko kotu na garantin tsarin mulki, aikin kiyaye fifikonsa akan ikon jama'a wanda, kamar yadda Dole ne masu iko su bi ta a kowane lokaci. A cikin kalmomin Kotun Tsarin Mulki, yana nuna cewa akwai wani aiki na biyayya ga Kundin Tsarin Mulki, wanda kiyaye shi ya zama wajibi ga hukumomin gwamnati. An ɗora wa majalisar cewa, a matsayinta na ikon da aka kafa, dole ne ta tabbatar da cewa, yanke shawara, a kowane lokaci, ya dace da tsarin mulki da sauran tsarin shari'a. Wannan lamari ne ga duk wani iko na jama'a, ba tare da wani uzuri ba, daga yanayin jiharmu a matsayin tsarin mulki da doka. 'Yancin 'yan majalisa ba za su iya zama wata hujja ba ga majalisar da ta dauki kanta a matsayin halaltacce don danganta ikon keta tsarin tsarin mulki. Akasin haka, ‘yan majalisar suna da aikin da ya dace na bin tsarin mulkin kasa, da jajircewa wajen gudanar da ayyukansu kamar yadda ya tanada. Lokacin da majalisa a sane, da gangan da kuma niyya ta yi watsi da ƙaƙƙarfan rukunan tsarin mulki, wanda aka bayyana a cikin STC 119/2011, wanda ke buƙatar ƙaramin ɗanɗano tsakanin shirye-shiryen majalisa da gyare-gyaren da aka gabatar, yana kawar da zato na haƙƙin tsarin mulki wanda za a yi amfani da shi ta hanyar ka'idoji. Babban kotuna sun yi karin bayani, wanda ya haifar da shiga tsakani na Kotun Tsarin Mulki. Idan wannan yana gudanar da keta haƙƙin 'yan tsiraru 'yan majalisa, wakilan jama'ar Spain, hanyar da ta wajaba ita ce roko ga amparo, saboda zargin cin zarafi na labarin 23 na Kundin Tsarin Mulki. A cikin wannan halin da ake ciki, matakan kariya suna yiwuwa, tun da yake an haɗa su a cikin labarin 56.2 na Dokar Tsarin Mulki na Kotun Tsarin Mulki: "The Chamber ko Sashe na iya ɗaukar matakan kariya da kuma shawarwari na wucin gadi kamar yadda aka tanadar a cikin tsarin shari'a, wanda. ta yanayin su, na iya amfani da su a cikin tsarin amparo kuma suna iya hana roko daga rasa manufarsa ". Ko da, a cikin taka tsantsan, tun da wannan ka'ida ta tanadar da shi. A takaice dai, kudurorin da kotun ta dauka a ranar Litinin din da ta gabata, duk da mamaki kamar yadda ake ganin ba su yi komai ba, sai dai a yi amfani da tsarin shari’a, tare da mayar da martani ga yiwuwar keta dokokin tsarin mulki na sauran hukumomin Jihohi. Yana yiwuwa a ce, ko da, - kwatanta miller Hansque, sa'a, har yanzu akwai alƙalai a Madrid. GAME DA MARUBUCI Carlos Bautista Ya kasance Likitan Shari'a tun 2014.